Skip to main content
Write a Review, Win $500! Help guests by leaving a review of your favorite dishes. Be entered in a drawing to win $500 on 2/1.
The Black Sheep Restaurant and Bar
  • Order Online
  • Private Events & Catering
  • Reserve
  • Gallery
  • The Kitchen
  • Press
  • Contact
  • __
barapples from cheese board

Deli Menu

Join The FlockReceive updates on special events, new menu items, menu reviews, and more!

Deli Menu

Sandwiches

Beef on Weck Sandwich

Choice of Beef Tongue or Top Round Beef. House Kimmelweck roll, horseradish, jus. Side of Timmy's chips and daily pickles.

Option to add Swiss or American cheese for +$1

Regular $13.50Add American Cheese $14.50Add Swiss Cheese $14.50
 

Chateau Blanc Sliders

$13.50

White Castle style. Mustard, pickles, American cheese, diced onion. 2 sliders per order. Served with fries and daily pickles.

 

Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup

$10

House white bread, American Cheese. Served with a cup of tomato soup.

 

House Bagel

 

Turkey Melt

$14

Smoked turkey breast, herb durum bread, Swiss cheese, bacon, jalapeno, ranch. Side of Timmy's chips and daily pickles.

22 pops3 reviews
 

BS Griddle Sandwich

Pancake sandwich. Available vegetarian, or with our bacon or sausage. Served with scrambled eggs, cheese, and side of hash brown.

Vegetarian $10Bacon $11Sausage $11Sausage and Bacon $13
11 pop1 review
 

Chicken Salad Sandwich

Herb durum roll, lettuce, sliced onion. Side of Timmy's chips and daily pickles. Option to add American or Swiss cheese for +$1.

Regular $14Add American Cheese $15Add Swiss Cheese $15
 

Ham & Cheese Sandwich

$13

House made baguette, Swiss Cheese, mustard. Side of Timmy's chips and daily pickles.

 

Smoked Brisket Sandwich

Quarter pound of Montreal style smoked brisket. Rye bread, mustard, garlic. Side of Timmy's chips and daily pickles. Option to add American or Swiss cheese for +$1.

Regular $15Add American Cheese $16Add Swiss Cheese $16
44 pops
 

Soups

Borscht (Vegetarian)

Aunt Sofia's recipe. Side of bread.

Half Pint $5Pint $10Quart $15
1 review
 

Roasted Tomato Soup (Vegetarian)

Fennel, garlic cream, side of bread.

Half Pint $5Pint $10Quart $15
 

Matzo Ball Soup

Root vegetables, chicken stock, side of bread.

Half Pint $5Pint $10Quart $15
 

Pastries

Black & White Cookies

NYC classic.

Single $2.50Half Dozen $1324 $24
 

Bread Pudding (Vegan)

$7.50
 

Chocolate Croissant

$6
 

Coffee Cake

$5

Oat streusel topping. Streusel layers. Individual servings.

 

Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies

Single $2.50Half Dozen $13Dozen $24
 

Carrot Cake

$5

Cream cheese frosting. Individual servings.

 

Chocolate Mousse

$6

Available by the half pint.

 

Sticky Toffee Pudding

$10

English date cake, whipped cream

Sticky Toffee Pudding
Featured
16 reviews
1124 pops16 reviews
 

Sides

House Made Bagels

 

Classic Potato Salad

American style.

Half Pint $3.50Pint $5Quart $10
 

Fries

$5

Ketchup.

 

Lardo

Choice of Rendered Pork Lard, Chicken Schmaltz, or Beef Fat. Various sizes.

Half Pint $5Pint $10Quart $15
 

Potato Pancake

 

Side Salad

$4.50

Pickled red onions, herb vinaigrette.

 

Bread Loaves

$6

Ellen's home made bread. Choice of White, Rye, Herb Durum, Sourdough Baguettes (2 per order), or Kimmelweck Rolls (6 pack).

 

Coleslaw

Red & Green cabbage, sesame, soy, garlic, shallot. Vinegar based.

Half Pint $3.50Pint $5Quart $10
 

House Pickles

Daily selection of quick pickles.

Half Pint $4Pint $7Quart $12
 

Pierogi

Cabbage and onion. Sour cream.

Order of 3 $10Order of 6 $18Order of 12 $34
 

Shmears

Assorted bagel spreads. Choice of Plain Cream Cheese, Veggie Cream Cheese, Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese, Smoked White Fish Cream Cheese.

Half Pint Plain Shmear $4Pint Plain Shmear $7Half Pint Veggie Shmear $6Pint Veggie Shmear $11Half Pint Smoked Salmon Shmear $9.50Pint Smoked Salmon Shmear $18Half Pint Smoked White Fish Shmear $8.50Pint Smoked White Fish Shmear $16
 

Timmy's Chips

$4.50

House made Saratoga chips.

 

N/A Drinks

Hot Coffee

Tipico Coffee.

8 oz $2.5016 oz $3.50
 

Lavender Lemonade

$3.50
 

Saratoga Sparkling Water

$3.50

12 oz.

 

Hot Chocolate

$4
 

Saratgoga Still Water

$3.50

12 oz.

 

Bottled Water

$1
 

Specials of the Week

Changes weekly

Meatloaf Dinner (Family Sized)

$40

Beef & pork meatloaf. Served with a quart of garlic mashed potatoes, quart of broccoli, pint of gravy. Serves 3.

11 pop
 

Braised Lamb Tongue

$30

Szechwan style. 8-10 oz. Sweet & sour cabbage, tangerine, Chinese chives. Served over rice, serves 2.

 
Made with by Popmenu
The Black Sheep Restaurant and Bar
Website Accessibility Assistance
Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window