“Turkey melt sandwich is a great winner. I loved everything about it.”

Carole

“Delicious coffee cake! Not too sweet and with a nice moist crumb. Would definitely buy again!”

Bkinar01

“We live in the 5 points neighborhood and LOVE LOVE LOVE The Black Sheep! The food is always outstanding no matter what we order and over the years there have been many many items tried (including from wayyyyy back to the old Elmwood location)! The Sticky Toffee Pudding in my opinion is the BEST dessert in the city! When we have people in town I always try to get there so they can try it and it never disappoints no matter how much I talk it up! I love they they have adapted to the current situation so they can keep their staff working and Buffalo Fed!”

Sbfrancis29

“Buffalo already had stiff sandwich competition and then Bo Peeps deli ascended upon us. Hearty bread matched with perfectly sliced smoked turkey all layered together with melted Swiss will make you weak in the knees. Highly recommended”

Scottrcollins

“The Pierogi is absolutely amazing. The ratio of filling to shell is perfectly balanced. Not too much stuffing, and not too little. The flavor is out of this world! Whatever they use to season this bad boy is so balanced that no one flavor outshines another. Black Sheep never disappoints!”

Abbypeters17

“Came in for dinner on 1/15/21- Our server Mackenzie was phenomenal. He offered my husband and I wonderful suggestions. I had the Turkey Melt... oh my god. I had no idea turkey could taste so good, the bread was out of this world. I also had the matzo ball soup, it was perfect. Black Sheep 🐑 is one of our favorite restaurants and is the first dine in experience we have had in MONTHS, and let me tell you; it did not disappoint. My husband had the Smoked Brisket- holy moly, was it good. Every single bite, better than the next. He also had the tomato soup which was jam packed with flavorful layers. And for dessert- duh. Sticky Toffee Pudding- the dessert that dreams are made of. (Chased down with the best hot chocolate I have ever had) Thank you to Ellen, Steve and the rest of The Black Sheep crew- you guys never cease to amaze me. What a way to kick off going out to restaurants again. Will absolutely be back over and over and over again.”

Caseyyeates

“Turkey melt sandwich is a great winner. I loved everything about it.”

Carole

“Delicious coffee cake! Not too sweet and with a nice moist crumb. Would definitely buy again!”

Bkinar01

“We live in the 5 points neighborhood and LOVE LOVE LOVE The Black Sheep! The food is always outstanding no matter what we order and over the years there have been many many items tried (including from wayyyyy back to the old Elmwood location)! The Sticky Toffee Pudding in my opinion is the BEST dessert in the city! When we have people in town I always try to get there so they can try it and it never disappoints no matter how much I talk it up! I love they they have adapted to the current situation so they can keep their staff working and Buffalo Fed!”

Sbfrancis29

“Buffalo already had stiff sandwich competition and then Bo Peeps deli ascended upon us. Hearty bread matched with perfectly sliced smoked turkey all layered together with melted Swiss will make you weak in the knees. Highly recommended”

Scottrcollins

“The Pierogi is absolutely amazing. The ratio of filling to shell is perfectly balanced. Not too much stuffing, and not too little. The flavor is out of this world! Whatever they use to season this bad boy is so balanced that no one flavor outshines another. Black Sheep never disappoints!”

Abbypeters17

“Came in for dinner on 1/15/21- Our server Mackenzie was phenomenal. He offered my husband and I wonderful suggestions. I had the Turkey Melt... oh my god. I had no idea turkey could taste so good, the bread was out of this world. I also had the matzo ball soup, it was perfect. Black Sheep 🐑 is one of our favorite restaurants and is the first dine in experience we have had in MONTHS, and let me tell you; it did not disappoint. My husband had the Smoked Brisket- holy moly, was it good. Every single bite, better than the next. He also had the tomato soup which was jam packed with flavorful layers. And for dessert- duh. Sticky Toffee Pudding- the dessert that dreams are made of. (Chased down with the best hot chocolate I have ever had) Thank you to Ellen, Steve and the rest of The Black Sheep crew- you guys never cease to amaze me. What a way to kick off going out to restaurants again. Will absolutely be back over and over and over again.”

Caseyyeates

“Turkey melt sandwich is a great winner. I loved everything about it.”

Carole

Welcome To The Black Sheep

Our Location

Buffalo

Hours

Leave Us a Review

Leave a Review

Welcome To The Black Sheep

Our Location

Buffalo

Hours

Leave Us a Review

Leave a Review

Coffee Cake